My six-year-old grandson recently asked his mother for a piece of paper and a permanent marker. He was writing his Christmas list to Santa and wanted at least a fighting chance of getting his heart’s desire. If the request for a puppy was yet again written in pencil, his mom would probably erase it.
When he explained the situation to me, he was emphatic. He doesn’t just want a puppy, he NEEDS a puppy. And for the record, if I were in charge of the North Pole, that kid would get a basket of puppies. But the current verdict is that jolly old St. Nick does not deliver live creatures.
Still, he is undaunted, and I have to admire his strategy. Even though he’s pretty sure he’s not getting a puppy, he doesn’t want his request erased by someone else.
The kid is onto something.
It made me think about my own wants and needs and how my penciled lists over the decades were revised to accommodate family, work, financial circumstances and the ordinary demands of life. Some wishes were postponed, others crossed out entirely. A few were erased so thoroughly the wish was just a ghost on the page.
And, to be honest, I was usually the one holding the eraser, digging into the paper hard enough to tear a hole.
There was a time when my greatest desire was an entire afternoon to read a book without interruption. Just four or five hours in a comfortable chair with a novel and absolutely nobody needing anything from me.
It seemed the ultimate indulgence, and one I never quite felt worthy of. There was always another task to complete, another essay to grade, another carpool to run. Even when an afternoon unexpectedly opened up, I felt compelled to fill it with something useful. I figured someday I’d have that kind of time.
Well, someday has arrived.
I’m retired or at least retired enough to have considerable control over how I spend my days. The children are grown, the carpools have ended, and I can travel, take classes, write, volunteer or sit on the porch and watch the painted buntings eat from my feeders.
And sometimes, right in the middle of the afternoon, I settle into my reading chair with a good novel. No guilt, no glancing at the clock, no mental inventory of all the things I ought to be doing instead. It’s every bit as wonderful as I imagined.
I’ve also discovered that with the gift of unstructured time, some of those other old wishes are worth pursuing.
Ever since I devoured every Nancy Drew book I could get my hands on, I’ve wanted to write a mystery of my own. That desire survived decades of writing in just about every genre except fiction. And then, in my first few years of retirement, I finally did it. I wrote a mystery novel. My heroine doesn’t wear white gloves or drive a blue roadster, but she’s got plenty of attitude and a knack for getting herself into trouble.
My daughters will tell you I sang the Rolling Stones’ “You Can’t Always Get What You Want” at them (off key) so often they still groan at the first notes. I meant it as wisdom. Now I wonder if I was just teaching them how to use an eraser.
These days there are still plenty of demands on my time, but I get to decide which ones deserve it. If a wish gets erased now, I’m the prime suspect.
So, after talking to a six-year-old, I’ve decided to make a new list. More afternoons spent reading go at the top, five hours at a stretch if I’m in the middle of a good part. Right under it: write the second mystery in the series.
My grandson probably isn’t getting a puppy this Christmas. But I hope he never loses the nerve to write his wishes in permanent marker.
Maybe he’ll let me borrow his.





